Meet Our Team

At Meagher Insurance Agency, we've built our team with individuals who have the highest standards for client communication and servicing. No matter who you interact with at Meagher Insurance Agency, you'll have the best experience possible.

Paul Meagher Jr

President

Paul Meagher Jr graduated from Honesdale High School and The University of Scranton. Paul is an active member of our community. Paul currently serves on the Boards of Directors of the Wayne County Planning Commission, the Greater Honesdale Partnership, and the Wayne Woodlands Manor Nursing Home. Paul is a member of Saint John the Evangelist parish in Honesdale where he serves as a lector. He is a past board member of the Wayne County Public Library and the Wayne County Chamber of Commerce. Paul and his wife Jenny live in Dyberry Township with their four children Paul III, Anne, Erin, and Claire.

Meet Paul Jr

Paul Meagher Sr

Commercial Insurance

Paul Meagher Sr. graduated from Honesdale High School and Mount Saint Mary’s College in Emmitsburg, Maryland. Very active in the community he has served as President of the Honesdale Little League Association, President of the Board of Directors of Wayne Memorial Hospital as well as President of the Wayne Economic Development Corporation. He has served on the Board of Directors of Honesdale National Bank for over 30 years. Served in the Pennsylvania Army National Guard for 12 years and was Commanding Officer of Company A 1^st Battalion Mechanized Infantry Honesdale. Paul is currently serving as Co-Chairman of the Board of Trustees of the Wayne County YMCA.

Meet Paul Sr

Maurice F. Meagher

Business Development

Maurice F. Meagher Jr. was born in the old hospital on Court Street in Honesdale. He spent many summers working the family farm in Pleasant Mount. Maurice graduated from Holy Cross and was commissioned as an officer in the US Navy serving in South America, Canada, Japan and Viet Nam. Maurice retired from the Navy after a 20 year career as a Captain. Maurice has always been a dedicated member of our community. He served on both the Wayne County Housing Board and the Wayne County Redevelopment Authority for 25 and 20 years respectively. Maurice was elected to and became President of Honesdale Borough Council. He was one of the founders of Honesdale Missy Basketball and coached both Missy and Biddy Basketball for many years. Maurice is a member of countless organizations his most relished is his service to Saint John the Evangelist parish in Honesdale where he currently serves as Head Usher.

Meet Maurice

Jackie Adams

Agent

Jackie is our Personal Lines Agent and has been with us for over 10 years. She loves being a part of our team and working in different areas to learn new things. Jackie has lived in Honesdale most of her life and volunteers at the local animal shelter. In her free time, she enjoys traveling and taking long walks with her dogs.

Meet Jackie

Jenn Mehrtens

Agent

Jenn has been with The Meagher Agency since December of 2021. She has lived in Wayne County for 30 years and has one daughter. Jenn works in our personal lines department. In her free time she enjoys spending time with her friends and family.

Meet Jenn

Matt Anderson

Agent/ Office Manager

Matthew is the Office Manager/ Agent in our Moscow location. He is also an experienced Investment Adviser Representative holding a Series 7, Series 63, and Series 66 License. For the past 27 years he has helped individuals and business’ develop financial plans. Matthew is an avid Equestrian and enjoys showing American Quarter Horses. Also, in his free time he enjoys paddle boarding and spending time outdoors.

Meet Matt

Lawrence B. Stich – MBA

Agent

Larry is a Medicare and Health Insurance specialist, and he can also help you with Life Insurance. Larry joined our team November of 2021 primarily to help folks with Medicare and Health Insurance. Larry has been in the Financial Industry for over 17 years in different capacities including that of Compliance officer. The Meagher Agency takes its responsibility of Fiduciary very seriously. Larry is a former Lieutenant of Marines and is dedicated to God, Country & his Family.

Meet Lawrence

Screenshot-2025-02-09-at-2.33.04 PM-600x600

Cathie Kelly

Agent

Cathie has been with our Agency for 32 years. She specializes in commercial and farm insurance but also likes to cross-sell personal lines as well. Cathie has lived in Honesdale her whole life and is married to her high school sweetheart. They have four children and 7 grandchildren. Cathie enjoys spending time outside relaxing and tending to her flower gardens.

Meet Cathie

Jason Badum

Agent

Jason grew up in Honesdale and enjoys helping and working with people. He is an avid painter and photographer who loves nature and the outdoors. He also believes everyone deserves great service, even if you’re not buying anything.

Meet Jason

Becky Simko

Agent

Becky is our Forest City Agent. She is originally from Falls, PA and moved to Pleasant Mount, PA in 2020 with her husband. She has three children who keep her busy when she is not working. She has worked in the Collision repair field since she was 16 and was a Physical Damage Appraiser since 2017. Becky loves to hunt, fish, and spend a lot of time outdoors. She has a passion for motorcycles and racing, and previously was a Volunteer Firefighter for two great companies out of Harding, PA and Orange, PA. Becky loves helping people in any way that she can and has always been a part of the community growing up. She continues being a part of the community now. She is excited to be a part of the Meagher Agency family, and can’t wait to help with your insurance needs!

Meet Becky

Valerie Gavin

Agent

Val is originally from New Jersey and moved to the Honesdale area in 1979. She began working with Meagher insurance in 1983. She later went on to open her own insurance agencies for 20 years! After retiring, she decided she missed her work and came back to the Meagher Agency! She has a heavy background in commercial line, but can help you with all of your insurance needs from home to auto to life and much more!

Meet Valerie

Laura Hooker

Agent

Laura Hooker is a life-long Wayne County resident along with her father, sister, and grandparents. She graduated from Honesdale High School in 2017. She resides in Honesdale with her family, boyfriend, and their dog. She enjoys going to new restaurants, being outside, and spending time with with friends and family.

Meet Laura

Patti Hoaglin

Agent

Patti grew up all over the United States and is a graduate of Sparta High School in Sparta, New Jersey. She now lives in Dingmans Ferry, Pennsylvania, with her husband. Patti has been an insurance agent in both New Jersey and Pennsylvania for 35 years, helping clients get the coverage they need. In her free time, she enjoys spending time with her grandchildren, riding roller coasters, attending concerts, and watching football.

Meet Patti

Deb Franklin

Agent

I am from Beach Lake and a proud parent of three children and a grandparent to a wonderful granddaughter. Family is at the center of my life, and I love spending time with them and my boyfriend. Together, we enjoy kayaking, riding on our side-by-side, and camping adventures with our four golden retrievers. I have a strong passion for helping others and have dedicated many years to serving my community as an EMT.

Meet Deb

Ted Tossio

Agent

With 30 years of customer service experience, including 25 years in the motorcycle industry, Ted brings a relationship-focused approach to Property, Casualty & Commercial Insurance. He is dedicated to helping clients find the right coverage and protecting what matters most. Outside of work, Ted enjoys staying active and prioritizing health and fitness.

Meet Ted

Christine Hirt

Agent

Christine Hirt joined Meagher Insurance & Financial Services in April 2026, bringing with her more than 20 years of experience in the Banking and Finance industry. Her extensive background has given her a strong understanding of the importance of financial security, planning, and building lasting relationships with clients.

As part of the Life, Health & Retirement Planning Department, Christine is passionate about helping individuals and families protect what matters most while working toward their long-term financial goals. She believes that financial planning should be personal, understandable, and centered around each client's unique needs and objectives.

Christine's goal is simple: to be a trusted resource for the community by helping families prepare for the unexpected, protect their loved ones, and take meaningful steps toward achieving their financial objectives.

Meet Christine

Jenny Meagher

Social Media Coordinator

Meet Jenny

Kerry Rodriguez

Social Media/ Marketing Manager

Kerry Rodriguez is the Social Media and Marketing Manager at the Meagher Insurance Agency. She graduated from Honesdale High School in 2019 and Lackawanna College in 2023 with a Bachelor of Science in Business and a concentration in Marketing.

Meet Kerry